Transcribed from newspaper articles by Karen S. Golden Rogers, 1997. The cemetery is located along PA Highway 66.
| Margaret Clover | d. 01 Feb 1846 |
| John M. McCormick | d. 04 Jul 1810 |
| Walker, no first name | d. 25 Oct 1815 |
| Corbett, Theodore | d. 04 Feb 1837 | McGarrah, Rt. Alexander | d. 26 Jun 1825 |
| McGarrah, Elenor | d. 06 Jan 1827 |
| McGarrah, Huldah | d. 1826 |
| McGarrah, Twins Joseph & Elenor | d. 29 Feb 1823 |
| Maffett, Nancy E. | d. 03 May 18__ |
| Guthrie, Jane | d. 23 Sep 1839 |
| Potter, Robert E. | d. 14 May 1834 |
| Potter, Eli | d. 30 Jun 1832 |
| Potter, Adam | d. 20 Jan 1834 |
| Potter, Lebrum H. | d. 12 Aug 1843 |
| Potter, James M. | d. 20 Feb 1836 |
| Gibson, William | d. 20 Feb 1836 |
| Gibson, Margaret | d. 21 Oct 1784 |
| Williams, Joseph | d. 02 Feb 1850 |
| Potter, James | d. 14 Feb 1855 |
| Potter, Mary | d. 03 Oct 1812 |
| Wilson, Sarah | d. 25 Mar 1823 |
| Wilson, Robert | d. 21 May 1822 |
| Clover, Frances | d. 07 Aug 1842 |
| Clover, Catherine | d. 12 Apr 8123 |
| Clover, Frances, first wife of Rev. Clover | d. 28 Dec 1827 |
| Clover, Hiram | d. 21 Mar 1878 |
| Clover, Isabelle Cathcart, second wife of Rev. Phillip Clover | d. 18 Sep 1886 |
| Port, John Q. | d. 06 Jul 1851 |
| Port, Ann | d. 09 Mar 1842 |
| Port, Lavellon | d. 01 Dec 1851 |
| Whiteman, Smith | d. 17 Dec 1923 (this is the last person buried in the Old Seceder Cem.) |
| Jones, John | d. 24 Dec 1858 |
| Jones, Rebecca | d. 20 Mar 1831 |
| Jones, Catherine | d. 14 Sep 1851 |
| Jones, Peter | d. 12 May 1829 |
| Maxwell, Robert | d. 17 Mar 1877 |
| Maxwell, Ann | d. 15 Jul 1859 |
| Dunlap, Margaret | d. 20 Apr 1817 |
| Corbett, John C. | d. 30 Mar 1853 |
| Corbett, Sarah | d. 25 Nov 1828 |
| Corbett, William | d. 13 May 1831 |
| McCormick, Joseph N. | d. 07 Dec 1840 |
| McCormick, Amantha | d. 03 Jul 1840 |
| Wilson, John | (no dates listed) |
| Roll, John, Jr. | d. 15 Jan 1816 |
| George, Samuel | d. 10 Aug 1884 |
| Guthrie, John M. | (no date on stone) |
| McConnell, Adam | d. 21 Jun 1842 |
| Williams, Mark | d. 05 Jun 1849 |
| Cochran, Mary & Elvira | d. 17 Nov 1842 |
| Cochran, Catherine | d. 26 Sep 1885 |
| Cochran, J.M. | d. 1865 |
| Cochran, Joseph | d. 19 Nov 1871 |
| Speer, James | d. 22 Jan 1873 |
| Speer, Sarah | d. 02 Feb 1892 |
| Speer, James | (no date of death) |
| Speer, George & Samuel | (no date of deaths) |
| Kady, Samuel | d. 12 Nov 1854 |
| Mitchell, Margaret | d. 11 Oct 1856 |
| Mitchell, Elizabeth consort of William Mitchell | d. 25 Apr 1827 |
| Mitchell, W.C. | d. 13 Oct 1851 |
| Clover, Rev. Phillip | d. 12 Apr 1888 |
| Wilson, Nancy, infant daughter of Samuel & Jean Love Wilson who left Ardstraw, County Tryone, Ireland, in the year 1798 to accompany her parents to the USA, died and was buried at sea at the age of four years. | |
In some information about the church and Seceder information from this article, it states that James McFadin Clover, infant son of Philip & Sarah Roll Clover was christened "Paul," and the child and parents are buried in Seceder cemetery. Judge Peter Clover was born in the Brush Run settlement in 1804.
The oldest stone in the cemetery is that of Mary, wife of James Potter, who died 04 Oct 1812 at age of 45 years. It is well known that there were earlier burials; however, no markers were placed at the burial plots.
From Carol-Jeanne Turk
I have been to Seceder Cemetery many times over the last 30+ years. I remember my brother and I tramped through the woods near the entrance (I think) and tripped over some headstones near a stream. Some had fallen over, and others were sinking in the soft, moist ground. I have searched for this part of the cemetery and have been unsuccessful in locating it again. It was to the left before going up the steep hill. I recall going along a very narrow and over-grown path through the woods, and the land opened up into a small, weedy area. The gravestones were to the far right end of the opening. Does this sound vaguely familiar to anyone? Has this area been searched for more, earlier headstones? I haven't been able to do this myself. I am not as agile as I used to be and would not be able to traipse through the woods like I did in my early twenties. Most of the people buried there were ancestors of mine: Clover, Cochran, Corbett. Carol-Jeanne Turk, P. O. Box 704, Oakhurst, NJ 07755-0704.